Propaganda is defined by Wordnet as “information that is spread for the purpose of promoting some cause.” Sounds innocent enough, right? However, Wikipedia gives us this definition:
Propaganda is the dissemination of information aimed at influencing the opinions or behaviors of people. As opposed to impartially providing information, propaganda in its most basic sense, often presents information primarily in order to influence its audience. Propaganda often presents facts selectively (thus lying by omission) to encourage a particular synthesis, or gives loaded messages in order to produce an emotional rather than rational response to the information presented. The desired result is a change of the attitude toward the subject in the target audience to further a political agenda.
Propaganda is the deliberate, systematic attempt to shape perceptions, manipulate cognitions, and direct behavior to achieve a response that furthers the desired intent of the propagandist.
—Garth S. Jowett and Victoria O’Donnell, Propaganda and Persuasion
SourceWatch gives a similar definition, and, like Wikipedia, provides a lot more detail sbout what exactly propaganda is. As we move toward tomorrow’s one year anniversary celebrating the PUMA Movement’s May 31, 2008 birth, I thought an examination of one of the prime elements that lead us to this point was overdue.
Many PUMA bloggers, myself included, in fact, perhaps myself primarily, have characterized the Obaminable tactics employed by David Axelrod and his minions on the Lyin’ King’s behalf, as Astroturf, when in truth, it is but one of the many tools of the Obagandists’ trade. Such mislabeling is understandable given Axelrod’s status as Master of Astroturf, a title bestowed upon him by Business Watch in their March 14, 2008 profile. However, Axelrod did not invent the tactic, nor is he a lone practitioner of the dark, dubious art. Dick Morris’ buddy, Mark Penn, CEO of Burson-Martsteller, and Hillary Clinton’s once chief strategist, is said to be well versed in the tactic. Penn, along with Morris, is also credited with being the architect of “triangulation” and pushing Bill Clinton to the right, as well as with identifying “soccer moms” as a group to be targeted and courted, like “active grannies.” Whatta maroon. FreedomWorks, Dick Armey’s Tea Party promoting Astroturfing machine is another, and DCI Group, another Republican public relations firm, is accused of posting a 2006 You Tube video spoofing Al Gore’s “An Inconvenient Truth” called “Al Gore’s Penguin Army” by “Toutsmith,” supposedly a 29 year-old amateur from Beverly Hills. I’m sure however, that without too much effort, we could find that just about every public relations firm in the world Astroturfs to some degree for clients corporate and political. Why not? It works.
According to Wikipedia, The Institute for Propaganda Analysis (1937-1942) outlined “seven common propaganda devices.” Though disbanded in 1942 for lack of funding, Aaron Delwiche’s Propaganda Critic took up the task in 2002, though it seems now to be largely inactive. The basis of concern regarding the use of the various tactics of propaganda in advertising corporate and political, is not just its effectiveness at brainwashing gullible people, though that is one of the primary goals, but the far more pressing concern is with the conditioning aspect of prolonged exposure to it, coupled with the sheer pervasiveness of the technique, which threatens to make even the most cynical critical thinkers gullible over time. Here’s Wikipedia’s description of the institute:
The Institute for Propaganda Analysis was a U.S.-based organization composed of social scientists, opinion leaders, historians, educators, and journalists. Created in 1937 by Kirtley Mather, Edward A. Filene, and Clyde R. Miller, the IPA formed with the general concern that increased amounts of propaganda were decreasing the public’s ability to develop their own critical thoughts. The purpose of the IPA was to spark rational thinking and provide a guide to help the public have well-informed discussions on current issues. “To teach people how to think rather than what to think.” The IPA focused on domestic propaganda issues that might become possible threats to the democratic ways of life.
The seven common propaganda devices outlined by the institute are:
Of course, Astroturfing, and the more recent mind control techniques employed by the Obamanoids to wrench control of the Democratic party, as well as the democratic process, as outlined in Time Magazine recently, were yet to be identified at the time of the institute’s existence. But, anybody who has been following the Pretendident’s Path to Power will easily recognize when and how the devices were used. Bloggers around the internet have illustrated many examples of how they feel propaganda is being used to mindfuck us all, like LezGetReal’s May 28, swine flu post, LightPondBlogger’s, “Propaganda or Opinion” examinationof the Sonia Sotomayor hoopla, and Shtuey’s delightfully wicked piece on marketing, pharmaceuticals, and, what else? Waffles Obiteme, at Oy…My Valve.
Obaganda is particularly insidious because of its fraudulent use to get a woefully unqualified, mediocre TelePrompTer Reader elected by manipulating public opinion through trickery and deceit. Selling a good product with clever marketing is one thing, successfully selling the equivalent of Pet Rocks and Ginsu knives as priceless, museum quality, collector’s items to the entire world is a Bernie Madoff shaming ripoff. And, when Obaganda, Astroturfing, intimidation, and the exploitation of mass guilt are combined into a potent cocktail, and sanctioned by Big Brother, the resultant onslaught and assault on the sensibilities becomes irresistible to a society conditioned by years of constant bombardment of similar tactics used to promote similarly deficient products. America, meet the McPresident. You want fries with that?
Somebody knew that America could be sold a bill of goods, and that this guy fit that bill. They paid a lot of money to see to it that the Obagandists had sufficient funds to complete their mission, and that no stone would be
unturned. From You Tube videos designed to promote the subliminal Mandingo fantasies of women who would never admit to such a thing, and promote their candidate’s Mac superiority over his opponent’s PC-ness, to online death threats, to glitzy, glamorous “branding” campaigns, to press memos highlighting opponent’s “unfortunate,” inadverdant, or even potentially deliberate racism, to the outright purchase of enough of the superdelegates he once disdained to ensure a favorable outcome to a righteous challenge to his quest for enough delegates to justify his party’s nomination, though even after the injustice was done he still nearly came up short, Obaganda permeated every aspect of the campaign, and, now, his pretendidency. Campaign donors who happen to own networks, newspapers, and the entire freaking internet worked, and continue to work, diligently to pretend that the razor thin resume of the part-time politician cum pew pimping community organizer has suddenly, miraculously, shhhh, don’t tell nobody-ly, become presidentially fat. And, the well-propaganda-fed sheeple ate, and continue to eat, it up. The fact that many of them seem ready to puke it back up is no real consolation, without another American Idol of the same corporate fueled type to capture their fancies, they will cling to the idea of him like a penniless abused woman, deliberately isolated from friends and separated from family, clings to the idea of love.
That’s the beauty of propaganda, the thing that takes the onus from those who foist it on the masses, at least in the perpetrators’ minds; in order for it to work, ya gotta wanna believe. You have to really want sea monkeys to grow in a glass of water to buy the packet, you believe rocks in a box are worth money or you don’t buy them, you don’t want to lose weight if you can’t have Twinkies or you don’t buy Miracle Slim, and your weenie’s embarrassingly tiny if you’re willing to send somebody money for a bottle of overpriced sugar pills to make it grow. But, that’s what puts the onus right back on the fraudsters, Obagandists especially. Like all the other shysters and scammers mentioned, and those who weren’t, Axelfraud, Inc. knew they were selling…nothing. However, they also knew sheeple would buy a pretty box if they could convince them that it had dreams, and hope, and change, and absolution it it, and they would feel like it was a bargain at the three quarters of a billion dollar price.
Manipulation to influence those who manipulate us is the order of the day at Camp Obajunk. Favored “journalists,” pseudo-journalists, talking heads, pundits, and bloviating blowhards (some who are some of the above, some, all of the above) are given preferential treatment; daily briefings, lunches, dinners, Superbowl parties, minute-by-minute emails and press releases, deep background info to be printed without attribution, etc., while those who speak ill of Baracus Hubris Maximus, (Hail, Caesar!) are relegated to the back of the plane, or hanging on to the undercarriage of the bus, if they get to go along at all. Corporate owned and operated suckophants are often given priority access to the Celebritician, like NBC was recently for an all-day, in-your-face taping of a mini-reality show to be aired at a later date. I’d tell you when it is, but I don’t want you to watch. It’ll probably be called Up Obama’s Nose, and, no matter how many people actually tune in, and how they really feel about it, we’ll be told millions of people creamed their jeans watching the elaborately staged production designed to look like an off the cuff, impromptu day-in-the-life of your average immortal superhero.
When ObAstroGanda is combined with good old-fashioned “ratfucking,” the cocktail becomes Molotov. Luckily, when the sheeple are cowed to the extent American voters are, one only need show the wick to keep them in line. So, Axelrove threatened his puppet’s famous “quiet riots” would erupt if Hillary Clinton kept threatening to kill his Spokesmodel, or refused to quit or the Usurper would rightfully lose. If one can keep sheeple busy obsessing over ACORN and the ObaMassah’s seemingly tenuous ties to the organization, one can deflect attention from the organization’s leader’s crimes, links to unions he founded, and money-laundering philanthropic organizations of the sort the Obamessiah Community Organizer organized communities on the board of.
(If you keep reading this far I’ll always try to reward you.
)
Wade Rathke is the founder of ACORN and co-founder of SEIU. He lost his job as Chief Organizer of ACORN due to the best efforts of the ACORN 8, a group
of former staffers assigned to look into financial irregularities in the organization of community organizers. Wade’s brother, Dale Radke, embezzled almost a million dollars and funneled it through another ACORN organization, Citizens Consulting, Inc., but he still had a job, too until June of last year, after working out a deal to pay the money back, $30,000 a year at a time. He got up to $210, 000, and some big old anonymous donor offered to pay it off, so, now he’s supposedly square. But, the ACORN 8 are pissed, and say they were fired for saying, logically, if you knew this shit was going on at the top for 8 years, what the hell else might be happening? Then, to make bad matters worse, they started looking into it.
Anita Moncrief testified that ACORN had ties to Obama above and beyond what the Obamanauts were owning up to, then claimed the New York Times sat on the story. (Remind you of the L.A. Times, Rashid Khalidi tapes cover-up story, much?) Anyway, the Obamalamadingdongs are currently in the process of Obagandizing that one. This guy, Michael Gaynor, whoever he is, (probably a conservative ‘Turfer) say Obama/ACORN sittin’ in a tree, K-I-S-S-I-N-G they’re so tight. But, what’s got my antennae throbbing enough to call on any PUMA willing to look into it, is the Tides Foundation. Wade’s bio boasts that he was a founding member of the board of this interesting organization, too. This little ACORN/Rathke money machine within a money making machine is a beaut. They take rich folks’ cash and put it where the rich folks’ want it to go without anybody else knowing about it. With SEIU alone throwing around numbers like 33 to 85 million smackeroos to the Obynasty, ya gotta wonder if there’s a Soros/Microsoft/GE/Google/Pepsi, etc., or other interesting connection to find.
I’ll be looking further into these bad boys in the very near future, but, before I go, I thought I’d leave you with a lovely little 1990 gem that lays out the Obama blueprint in a nutshell. Tammerlin Drummond, an L.A. Times
reporter back then, wrote a profile of Harvard University’s sophomore editor of the Law Review. If you changed the dates and a few verb tenses, it could have been written any time in the past 10 years, and attributed to any of the mainstream media or Blogger Bullies of Cheetoville. In fact, I’m sure large amounts of it have been, and, I’m equally sure that’s because they got the unattributed text in an Axelrovefraud email, press release or memo. All the building blocks of the ObaCampaign are laid out in black and white, and, like most Obama supporters who have out lived their usefulness, Tammerlin’s under the bus somewhere by the bay.
Given the fragility of the carefully constructed protective shell the ObaMeisters have built around the Chirping Baby Chick-in-Chief, Team Obabysitter has to watch over its fledgling like an adoptive Mother Hawk entrusted to nurture and protect a quail egg. Thus, every “I” and every “T” on every word written is dotted, crossed and double checked before it’s placed in large print on the Trusty TelePrompTer of Truthiness. There’s not a whole lot of reason to doubt that every keystroke on every computer that dares to look at the UnWizard behind the invisible curtain with the clarity of a child viewing a strutting nude Emperor In His Own Mind is monitored, too. Somehow, paid ‘Bots seem to have an uncanny 6th sense when it comes to rejection of their Beloved, and pounce like hungry, wild-eyed, banshee-tiger cross-breeds from a madman’s lab, with claws out and teeth bared anytime anyone anywhere says anything that can’t be described as a verbal genital lick. Thus, the pre-schoolers over at Stupid Rumpies have an excuse for their existence; they’re Obacolyte AxelSoldiers on a Crusade-worthy mission to perpetuate the sham at all costs. Either that, or, they’re just a bunch of assholes with collective woohoos big enough to fill a thimble with room left over for a thumb, a marble, two Cheerios, a roll of LifeSavers, a pack of Trojans and the equivalent weight of their tiny pea brains.
I’m sure this information can be easily verified at any of the regular circle jerks they constantly engage in as they one-hand type their equally smegma-tainted filth on their crusty keyboards located in their Addams Family basements; that is, when they’re not shitting in their hands or eating yellow snow. Buncha booger sucking diddletwits. Your mama got pulled off the tarmac by the Secret Service.
Remember PUMAs, it’s complacency that is our enemy; critical thinking and healthy skepticism are our long suits. But, our ace-in-the-hole, the strongest trait we have, and must never lose, is our thoroghly justified, well earned, complete, total, fucking rage.
[...] social networks in the Obama administration in her post Tim Geithner Rules the World. Yesterday Cinie’s World explored (whipped up a 7 course meal) on propaganda, ACORN and Obama (at least). Obama Lover [...]
What carolflowery said!
… and:
The success of Axelrove’s astroturf – from now on propaganda – is the reason I want PUMAs, and others who think alike, to continue to repeat the truth.
According to the IPA most of the “Propaganda Techniques” have been used during wartime!
And was useful to Obama during the election! Go figure!
But it makes me wonder: Is it actually possible to convince people of the truth, without using any of these techniques?
And how about this one:
”Also, the propagandist, especially during speeches, may attempt to increase the illusion through imperfect pronunciation, stuttering, and a more limited vocabulary. Errors such as these help add to the impression of sincerity and spontaneity.”!
Has this been a conscious part of the manipulation too? Has the Obots seen the “mediocre TelePrompTer Reading” as proof of Obama’s sincerity?
Nah, couldn’t be! … could it?
The only technique I so wish someone had used during the election, is “ridicule”!
Done with humour I’m sure it would have devastated the narcissist!
… and what Woodhull said too!
Cinie,
Thanks for this, most especially for the reminder that PUMA (however one wants to define PUMA) rage is essential to clearing the decks and getting to the bottom of all this.
All the stops were pulled out for Obama no doubt in my mind, however, i still cant get over the nearly billion he pulled in to make sure all that propaganda worked and that it cost that much to make it work and didnt he have some money left over, wow, wish he could get our budget to work like that:)
The scariest thing about Obama, are the people, the people who actually believe he will save them, the ones who truly believe if you didnt vote for him you are a racist, the people who have the power now to just let off 3 thugs who intimidated voters at a Philadelphia voting poll, the people who turned on Hillary Clinton as if they didnt ever know or work with her, people like Nancy Pelosi who has never spent one hour losing sleep over her down right bias towards Hillary and her love affair with Obama, people like Spector, who can actually get away with just sayin, im goin dem because i will lose if i stay republican, people who bought the plates and cups and the coins as commeratives, people that are living in 2009 and as suggested by many including Oprah we feel guilty for slavery days, people who never voted all their lives and went out because a black man was running. See, Im afraid of people who buy this shit. He aint nuffin but a skinny mixed race punk with a law degree who loved rev wright and everything he said and preached about. He’s goin the make that speech in Eygpt and by cracky, he’ll show them we love them and all will be fine. Ded gummit.
It’s been a long , strange year , and people are begining to wake up . What happens next ?
“The line for the “sheeple” forms over here”. And leave your powers of reasoning and critical questioning for another time. This man “can do no wrong” and even if it is not evident or clear, he is a master politician so say the media.
Barf!
Cinie, sometime within the last year I too came across the Tides Foundation in some of my research. I will have to go back and check but IIRC, I found William Ayers name–I believe he was on their Board of Directors.
Well, Cinie, I finally ‘get it’ why one cannot associate with the ‘ratfuckers’. It’s like scraping the ’slime’ off the top of the water to get to the ‘good’ water beneath- no matter how careful you are- you still get some slime!
Love your posts! always!
As always I’m in awe of your post(s). And as always I have to go back and reread it. You just supply so much information!
(How many hours is in your day, again?)
Also while reading, memories resurface.
How about the “You’ll be the first to know, who I pick for VP, if only you give me your number”?!
Har, har, how many million [idjits] bought into that?
But you know what, Cinie. I refuse to believe, that investigative journalism is dead in the US.
There just have to be someone else besides you out there.
There have to be!
… well, well, there actually is a site with (almost) that name:
centerforinvestigativereporting.org
(Won’t make it a link, as I know nothing about it.)
Rage plus critical thinking plus skepticism. That’s a definition of PUMA that I can identify with.
Great post, Cinie.
I worked on this piece all night and morning so I didn’t see your piece until I was done, or I would have added it right away.
Yes! That;s an awesome, definition!!
Way to go Cinie!
SYD
Cine, thanks for your thorough insiders knowledge of the ways of propaganda, particularly Obamaganda.
This is a topic well worth exploring if we mean to keep a calm, clear and skeptical head.
Thanks, PB. As soon as I saw the Tides Foundation, I thought it might be something you might want to exercise your excellent investigative skills on. It seems potentially very juicy.
Politics in the modern (postmodern?) age is very much like an advertising campaign, I guess. Brand loyalty is very good, of course, but even better is to get the consumer/”citizen” to go that extra mile, and to willingly, or even enthusiastically, if not ecstatically, consent to her own bamboozlement/oppression.
Signed,
A “soccer mom” (a mother of a small boy who plays a sport, who probably resents being reduced to a demographic stereotype along such lines, but who understands that this is the logic of consumer capitalism, after all) who is also a Catholic (who thinks Father Pfleger [that misogynistic fuckwad] is an opportunistic padre of the worst sort, and also an obvious glad-hander and a shameless grandstander).
You just keep rocking the Casbah, Cinie, you truly do.
Thanks Honora, I thought you were mad at me, I hadn’t heard from you in so long.
As for “soccer mom,” toldja Penn is a maroon. Your little man sounds precious.
TIDES Foundation…It is run by Drummond Pike who paid off Dale Rathke’s bill from ACORN for his embezzlement. The Tides Foundation takes money from private foundations and funds other groups like ACORN with it. Some of the seed money for The Tides Foundation came directly from George Soros….it is somewhat like a money laundering scheme but legal.
Got a bit further and look into The Tides Center it is an offshoot of The Tides Foundation…and they are heavily into funding Health Care for America Now which ACORN is a part of.
There is a tenuous link at best between all of these groups and GE. I am still looking to see if GE has a charitable arm that donates to causes like the Tides.
I am currently working with Marcel Reid of the ACORN-8. They have filed RICO charges against ACORN in 14 states. There will be more to come on that soon. They are trying to find a Public Interest law firm to handle filing more RICO charges in all the states. They need donations to continue their work.
Check out my article:
http://msplaceddemocrat.com/http:/msplaceddemocrat.com/marcel-reid-and-the-acorn-8-need-our-support/
Lend what ever support you can to the ACORN-8…help them complete their mission.
Thanks, I thought the payoff for Rathke might have come from Pike, but hadn’t gotten far enough to back it up. There’ll be a post of its own coming sooner or later, but, since I’m not all the way convinced who’s the good guys and bad, I’ll wait until I am. I’m just not ready to jump on the right wing “fuck ACORN” train until I have presentable proof. Whatever I find I’ll post, I just want the info, pro and con, to come from the least partisan sources I can find.
But, keep me in the loop on what you find. I’ll check in on you and do the same if something comes out on my end.
RBO is excellently, painstakingly researched and connects the o-so-interwoven dots. And RBO has a search function!
the real Barack Obama, search results: Tides Foundation
I’m sure however, that without too much effort, we could find that just about every public relations firm in the world Astroturfs to some degree for clients corporate and political. Why not?
Answer = Integrity/respect for fella human beings
Great post and thanks for the lotsa links, Cinie.
Holy chit. That’s more links than I research in a week. I’m still dying over Gore’s penquin army. I bet he owns controlling interest in every company that stands to profit from his convenient inconvenient truth.
I think I’m Google-addicted, Uppity. Think I can find a 12 Click program?
Cine, try Scroogle which will link you to Google sans Google’s creepy Big Brother functions:
Scroogle scraper
Thanks guys. I woulda had this up late last night/early this a.m. but the cable went out.
HT, I’m sure Hoover would have had a field day, too, but with FISA on their side the Obacrats are scarier. Seems the wrong people learned plenty from history.
What crazy horse and PJ said.
BTW, while reading through, that niggling deja vu thingie started to kick in….. I was just a very young sprout during the McCarthy era, but I remember some of it vividly. He had the Hollywood and Corporate elite backing him, and he had J. Edgar controlling and feeding him the information. (J. Edgar had illegal tampering on his side, I’m sure he’d swoon with ecstasy today, when it is all legal in the GWOT where americans spy on other americans with impunity!) The propaganda of that time was equal to what is happening today. Seems we don’t learn from history, and as a result are doomed to repeat the same mistakes….over and over and over again.
I love the last paragraph:
Remember PUMAs, it’s complacency that is our enemy; critical thinking and healthy skepticism are our long suits. But, our ace-in-the-hole, the strongest trait we have, and must never lose, is our thoroghly justified, well earned, complete, total, fucking rage.
Now that would be great to have on a bumper sticker….except it’s too long….dang, always a catch!
Great post, as always!
Wow, you hit that one out of the Park. Great, just great. I was wondering were you’ve been. Worth the wait. Hillary/Cinie 2012.
Cinie, I am laughing so hard I can hardly type but I just wanted to say GREAT POST!