
First of all, let me say, I hate poetry. All of it. I don’t get it. What’s the point, you got a story to tell, tell it, and be done with it. Reading or hearing a bunch of silly, pseudo-romantic, self-important, rambling examples of verbal masturbation about nothing; sheer pointless twaddle strung together, but going nowhere, pisses me off. I will admit to an affinity for Dr. Seuss; no wasted words, there. Lyricists, rappers, and even jingle writers know how to tell a freakin’ tale and get it over with. And, though some people say Shakespeare was a poet, I think of him as a playwright, a story-teller, not an aimless word-spinning thought wanderer. To tell you the truth, when I am confronted with the
“Oh, though a man be a duck
The shitting bird screeches
Teach water of the sun
Still my gums from violet”
crowd, my eyes start to bleed. That being said…
Didja know the Associated Press held an “Ode to Obama” inaugural poem contest, and that a man from Gilbert Arizona, Ted Newman, won one of ten finalist spots? Betcha didn’t. You can find the entries here. Don’t know why you would want to, but there it is. Obama’s choice, a former fellow University of Chicago faculty member, Elizabeth Alexander, who declined AP’s contest invitation, will read her original, official inaugural poem Tuesday. The Venus Hottentot, one of Alexander’s most famous poems, about a South African woman, Saartjie Baartman, put on public display in life and death for European amusement, follows:
The Venus Hottentot (1825)
Elizabeth Alexander1. Cuvier
Science, science, science!
Everything is beautifulblown up beneath my glass.
Colors dazzle insect wings.A drop of water swirls
like marble. Ordinarycrumbs become stalactites
set in perfect anglesof geometry I’d though
impossible. Few willever see what I see
through this microscope.Cranial measurements
crowd my notebook pages,and I am moving closer,
close to how these numberssignify aspects of
national character.Her genitalia
will float inside a labeledpicking jar in the Musee
de l’Homme on a shelfabove Broca’s brain:
“The Venus Hottentot.”Elegant facts await me.
Small things in this world are mine.2.
There is unexpected sun today
in London, and the clouds that
most days sift into this cage
where I am working have dispersed.
I am a black cutout against
a captive blue sky, pivoting
nude so the paying audience
can view my naked buttocks.I am called “Venus Hottentot.”
I left Capetown with a promise
of revenue: half the profits
and my passage home: A boon!
Master’s brother proposed the trip;
the magistrate granted me leave.
I would return to my family
a duchess, with watered-silkdresses and money to grow food,
rouge and powders in glass pots,
silver scissors, a lorgnette,
voile and tulle instead of flax,
cerulean blue instead
of indigo. My brother would
devour sugar studded non-
pareils, pale taffy, damask plums.That was years ago. London’s
circuses are florid and filthy,
swarming with cabbage-smelling
citizens who stare and query,
“Is it muscle? bone? or fat?”
My neighbor to the left is
The Sapient Pig, “The Only
Scholar of His Race.” He playsat cards, tells time and fortunes
by scraping his hooves. Behind
me is prince Kar-mi, who arches
like a rubber tree and stares back
at the crowd from under the crook
of his knee. A professional
animal trainer shouts my cues.
There are singing mice here.“The Ball of Duchess DuBarry”:
In the engraving I lurch
toward the belles dames, mad-eyed, and
they swoon. Men in capes and pince-nez
shield them. Tassels dance at my hips.
In this newspaper lithograph
my buttocks are shown swollen
and luminous as a planet.Monsieur Cuvier investigates
between my legs, poking, prodding,
sure of his hypothesis.
I half expect him to pull silk
scarves from inside me, paper poppies,
then a rabbit! He complains
at my scent and does not think
I comprehend, but I speakEnglish. I speak Dutch. I speak
a little French as well, and
languages Monsieur Cuvier
will never know have names.
Now I am bitter and now
I am sick. I eat brown bread,
drink rancid broth. I miss good sun,
miss Mother’s sadza. My stomachis frequently queasy from mutton
chops, pale potatoes, blood sausage.
I was certain that this would be
better than farm life. I am
the family entrepreneur!
But there are hours in every day
to conjure my imaginary
daughters, in banana skirtsand ostrich-feather fans.
Since my own genitals are public
I have made other parts private.
In my silence I possess
mouth, larynx, brain, in a single
gesture. I rub my hair
with lanolin, and pose in profile
like a painted Nubianarcher, imagining gold leaf
woven through my hair, and diamonds.
Observe the wordless Odalisque.
I have no forgotten my Xhosa
clicks. My flexible tongue
and healthy mouth bewilder
this man with his rotting teeth.
If he were to let me rise upfrom his table, I’d spirit
his knives and cut out his black heart,
seal it with science fluid inside
a bell jar, place it on a low
shelf in a white man’s museum
so the whole world could see
it was shriveled and hard,
geometric, deformed, unnatural.
Hey! I like poetry okay. I have spells where I really enjoy devouring lots of them, then I have times when I can’t be bothered with deciphering and all that. The one about the Hottentot is not bad from her. I wrote a post about the Venus Hottentot sometime in 2007 I believe because it is a story that is near and dear to my heart and not enough people know about it. It would have been nice to see a movie made about it, but at this point in time, race relations might make it not such a good film to release right now. I don’t know. Maybe I’m overly cautious, but something in the wind seems weird to me and I think even with a “black” president, there is something in the air that feels like trouble…..
Zee, my poem was meant to be crappy, was your comment?
“The first poem is crap I made up off the top of my head.”
And it shows.
Shtuey, SuperPampers/Urkel Superman/Clark Kent, perfect.
Sister, I know nobody can hate all of anything, but I grew up with stream-of-consciousness, beat, spoken word kind of stuff that often just sounded like stoned people hollering, or, school assigned eye-booger inducing swill rhapsodized by that one teacher every kid hated.
Shtuey, ooooooh, I’m gonna get you! You know why, my brother.
Dances, speaking only for myself about poetry love. I kinda like people who like GOOD poetry, in fact. Doesn’t make me like poetry any better, though.
Libbygurl, I read Obie’s poem somewhere, but didn’t know ANYBODY, even HuffPo, thought it was better than dreck.
Ugh! There’s too much pretentious blather in modern poetry that has driven away the likes of you and me. I’m hardly ever blown away by poetry, but well-written, simple prose will always captivate me (think Brit writers Graham Greene, Somerset Maugham). Shakespeare DID write poetry – but so brilliantly – unlike the rubbish self-indulgent romantic embarrassments who dare call themselves poet.
For my money, your made-up poem is actually brill in its barbed mockery of these pseudo-poets. Like the one picked by BH0.
Of course, here’s the ‘poem’ by BH0, much lauded by HuffnPuffpost:
UNDERGROUND
Under water grottos, caverns
Filled with apes
That eat figs.
Stepping on the figs
That the apes
Eat, they crunch.
The apes howl, bare
Their fangs, dance,
Tumble in the
Rushing water,
Musty, wet pelts
Glistening in the blue.
==========
I love poetry…
poetry is to prose
what bumperstickers are to philosophy…
it gets to the point, and quickly.
just sayin’
Oh, and it’s a given, not all poetry is good.
I blogged about Ms. Alexander last month when I heard her say, “…I am the vessel for the poem. It’s not about the poet at that moment, it’s about the poem. So the pressure — the challenge — is to write a poem that can serve … all of those expectant, gathered millions and to let the poem be what calms my nerves when I am up there. To let myself remember that I am there to deliver these words and these words have been commissioned to deliver a very, very amazing moment.”
Pukey McPukely. What’s so amazing? The guy cheated his way in, beat two women down to do it, and set back race relations 40 years. I think what Ms. Alexander is excited about is her soon to be instant fame. That One’s sheep will now buy anything with her name attached.
What a contrast. Clinton had Maya, a woman of true class, modesty, and talent.
I think it’s very appropriate that a poseur President picked a poseur poet.
In answer to your question as to who Pampers’ Clark Kent is…that’s easy: Steve Urkel
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ncw70Hw1ffs
BTW, when you said, “Obama as Denzel…well, let’s just say I’ve never been that drunk,” I hurt myself laughing.
I’ve read poetry that has moved me, or simply stuck with me. A lot is pretentious twaddle. The Hottentot above ain’t so totten-hot. Yours is kinda funny, actually.
I’ve written poetry within the context of my novels. There it doesn’t have to be good if it fits the story. (No, not published, though I’m always glad to send copies out to anyone interested.)
Cinie, one poem you might find meaningful if you haven’t read it is “The Box,” by Lascelles Abercrombie. I heard it read many years ago on The Smothers Brothers Show and it has haunted me ever since.
Or for a different Valentine’s twist, try “One Perfect Rose,” by Dorothy Parker.
Then there’s Ogden Nash and his humor. And one of my favorites, whose author I never knew, so I can’t credit:
My dog was dying by inches
And dying by inches is hard
So I took him out to the alley
And let him die by the yard.
Sick and a bad pun. What more can you ask?
Cinie, of course I know you weren’t calling me out. I’ve been here for so many months, I’m starting to know some things about you, and I know that if you had a problem with me you would be quite forthright. Of course we are okay! I love your style of writing, (although sometimes I miss nuances) and though I don’t comment all that often, I’m here every day, and will continue, as long as you post! As a matter of fact, I’ve lurked at the Confluence since it started, and was delighted to see you start posting there as well, and I hope you continue to do so. I’m an unabashed fan!
I was apologizing for not giving close enough attention to the content of your post – to the extent that I commented in a superficial manner (i.e. I love some poetry, you don’t, I want you to like some yadda yadda). You deserve better than that.
HT, What are you apologizing for? I wasn’t calling you out; if that’s the way it read I apologize. I was mainly just trying to clear up the point that while I don’t like poetry, I can appreciate that some do, in my own snarky way. Sorry for the confusion, hope we’re still good.
I am embarrassed, Next time, I’ll read more carefully, although I still am not enamored by this particular poetry. Mea culpa.
HT, The Venus Hottentot tells a compelling true story of a tragic situation by an “award-winning” poet.
The first poem is crap I made up off the top of my head.
The poem you posted tells a story any human being can relate to. I can appreciate it and wish it was a novel at the same time, can’t I? Though, to be honest, deep, heavy prose doesn’t appeal to me either. I like snarky, funny, smart kinds of stuff and totally mind-numbing commercial tacky bestselling adventure/mystery/legal thrillers. Gimme a limerick by James Patterson, Janet Evanovich, Blair Underwood, Lisa Scottoline, Christopher Moore, or John Grisham; or a boy standing on a burning deck singing “my baloney has a first name…” and I’m all set.
Besides, my aversion to the form is my own, some of my best friends are poets.
P.S. I know all about living in one’s own world as a child, Sister Survivor.
Reaction to poetry is a very personal experience, and I understand your aversion, particularly if these two are examples of that. experience
I happen to love some – but not all – poetry, as I love some – but not all – plays, novels, non fiction books. Begging your indulgence, but as an example of one I love
There are more ways to abandon a child
than to leave them at the mouth of the woods.
Sometimes by the time you find them, they’ve made up names
for all the birds and constellations, and they’ve broken
their reflections in the lake with sticks.
With my daughter came promises and vows
that unfolded through time like a roadmap and led me
to myself as a child, filled with wonder for my father
who could make sound from a wide blade of grass
and his breath. Here in the stillness of forest,
the sun columning before me temple-ancient,
that wonder is what I regret losing most; that wonder
and the true names of birds.
—Susan Goyette
Perhaps because of my past; living in my own world as an abused child; this poem speaks to me personally. And it is beautifully phrased, and simply stated. I understand that you’ll hate it, but to me, it’s evocative and soothes me. (Ii.e. I wasn’t nuts back then!)
The two poems you’ve presented are pretentious gobbledygooky propaganda pieces that will last as long as Leni Riefenstahl’s movies, although to be honest, Leni had more talent. However, Leni is not remembered for her talent, much as Tokyo Rose is not remembered for her voice and scintillating repartee.
Speaking of Leni and TRose, this poetry contest is just one additional situation (among too many) that gives me the willies.